I watched and loved “Twin Peaks” in 2018, but I read spoilers whenever I watch scary shows so I can brace myself. I decided I hated the way “Twin Peaks” was going to end so I stopped watching before the last two episodes (of the original Season 2) and wrote my own, better ending!
Okay well since I’ve made some weird decision to not watch the last two episodes of Twin Peaks because I highly suspect I’ll be disappointed I am going to take the liberty of writing out a way I’d prefer things to happen.
Okay so where I’m at like Windom Earle just killed some random dude who was a pawn and was like, “next time it will be someone you know” and he clearly has plans to kill the queen aka the girl who wins Miss Twin Peaks and it’s also pretty clear that it’s going to be Annie because Cooper is head over heels in love with her (and it’s super cute) and so he’s going to have to go rescue her from Windom Earle.
But I hate all of that and tbh isn’t it ultimately super cliched even though it’s a weird supernatural horror crime drama?
So this is what I’m proposing instead.
For once, Cooper does his damn job and gets ahead of Windom Earle. He knows that Windom Earle is hanging onto Leo so they kind of set up Windom Earle. And they do it in a super risky way, but who cares it builds suspense. So Cooper stops taking his chess advice from Pete, and he makes this really bold move in the paper that Windom isn’t expecting but at this point Windom has gone so batshit crazy that he’s just like, kind of not thinking logically anymore. Like sure, sure, Windom is a “genius” but he’s also psychotic and wants to murder people and Cooper has basically set up Windom to kill the person he knows so he’s like, “go ahead and do your worst” but maybe doesn’t say that outright.
So the person who is the bait is Harry which is SUPER scary for all of us as viewers because we’re like, “oh shit is Windom going to kill Harry!?” but like of course our heroes are now finally three steps ahead of the game.
And how are they three steps ahead of the game, you might ask?
Well Cooper and Annie are super in love and they bone and it sends them directly to The White Lodge because they are in such true love that them consummating their love opens some kind of portal. There is of course a white flash.
While they are in the White Lodge they obviously learn about the power of love, and maybe an OWL is like, “hey um, look, I’ve been really unfairly demonized during this whole show. The owls are not what they seem because we’ve been made to seem EVIL but actually we’re super chill and cute. Well, okay so we eat big rats at night and are kind of associated with the dark arts sometimes, but also we’re symbols of wisdom and truth and the rodent population really would be out of control without us so I’m just saying.”
And Annie is like, “Um, what?”
Just kidding. This is not what the dialogue would be. The owls in Twin Peaks would obviously speak much more pretentiously in such an over-the-top formal way that I would love it and it would make me laugh a lot but I am not yet fluent in Lynchian dialogue. The owls would still say something like, “You are not what you seem.”
and Cooper would be like, “wait! Tell me more!”
And then the owl would say, “The greatest thing you’ll ever learn, is just to love, and be loved in return.” and the owl would be played by John Leguizamo in an owl suit.
Um whatever I have no idea what would happen at the White Lodge to be honest, this is a first draft of this ending pitch, but basically whatever happened at the White Lodge would be along the lines of “the greatest power is love” (because Windom Earle went on a really annoying rant about how the Black Lodge had a lot of power and I think that our culture has a really stupid, annoying, patriarchal white supremacist understanding of power and so in this ending we’re not going for that angle).
Also Cooper is probably like, “yeah I know” because he’s a Tibetan Buddhist after all.
So Cooper leaves the White Lodge kind of feeling like he’s leaving not knowing anything he didn’t already know and he’s kind of disappointed, and Annie is just sort of wigged out a little but also sort of amazed and generally just processing.
But both Cooper and Annie leave (with their White Lodge tattoos) and they also start to realize that they both “know” certain things without knowing how they know. It’s like they have x-ray vision, or like they can read spoilers on the Internet, or like the premise that was set up was so fucking obvious that anyone could see it a million miles away and so they’re like, “maybe these aren’t magic gifts from the White Lodge, maybe this was all just obvious.”
So Annie knows she’s being set up to be murdered at the Miss Twin Peaks thing.
So Cooper just “knows” that Windom Earle will take his Harry bait and that they can trick Windom Earle.
And Cooper keeps saying to himself, “I am not what I seem… I am not what I seem” because that’s what the owl told him. And then he suddenly realizes that he’s totally cool with dying kind of like how Buffy was totally cool with dying at the end of Season 5 and so he’s going to potentially sacrifice himself.
So Windom Earle is after Harry but when he “catches up” with Harry (who is the Knight in the chess version of the murder games if you’re playing along at home) he finds out that he’s really being confronted with Cooper.
So Windom Earle is all confused because he wasn’t expecting Cooper and Cooper is like, “well what’s it going to be Windom?” and Cooper is like, “he might kill me but if he does it’s going to be okay because the game will be over because he’ll have defeated the King.”
Windom doesn’t kill him because he’s just pissed off that Cooper keeps breaking the rules and then Cooper is like, “well you broke the rules too dude and also there’s a double standard in this game because I don’t kill someone every time I take one of YOUR pieces so all the murder is really one-sided like don’t I get something for my moves?”
He obviously doesn’t say that, but maybe he’s thinking it.
So Windom Earle and Cooper both part ways and Windom is like, “well I’ll see you at Miss Twin Peaks, won’t I?”
and Windom kind of like, doesn’t really have an advantage anymore and they aren’t even really playing a version of chess anymore, and that’s partly how Cooper got ahead of him was by transcending the set-up of the game and CREATING HIS OWN VERSION OF THE GAME *ahem*
So then at Miss Twin Peaks everyone is like a little on edge because they’re like, “who is going to get murdered tonight?”
Ben Horne hosts and he is fucking HILARIOUS as he goes on and on and on about a woman’s virtues like her intelligence and empathy for small forest animals like the endangered pine weasel.
The girls all give a speech about saving the forest.
Shelly acts confused and is like, “trees are good.”
Donna is super fucking pretentious and annoying and is like, “The deciduous forests are part of the life cycle that connects us all.”
Lana just like, licks her lips for that old dude.
Audrey doesn’t participate because she’s too busy running her loser dad’s business.
And Annie gives an eloquent and thoughtful speech from the heart so obviously she wins.
But then right at that moment Windom Earle comes out guns ablazing and shooting, but an owl swoops into his face and distracts him and so he doesn’t shoot Annie… he shoots… MIKE!!!!
And Mike is hit and he goes down and he’s like, toast.
I mean there have to be some deaths, this is the season finale and the big climax.
And you know who’s super fucking pissed, don’t you?
NADINE.
So then Nadine LOSES IT and she GOES for Windom Earle and like, honestly beats him to a pulp. It’s really bloody. Like worse than any of the violence we’ve seen up to that point. It’s almost like a Quentin Tarantino movie, especially since she already has an eyepatch.
So Windom is dead.
And then Nadine gets up and brushes herself off, and she runs over to Mike and is sobbing. Aw, it’s sad.
She looks around the room and runs off into the woods. There’s another white flash. We assume she’s been taken to the White Lodge.
Ed and Norma get married finally and Hank is locked up for good.
I don’t know how to wrap up the Donna’s mom and Ben Horne thing honestly and it was a stupid subplot to begin with, and I don’t like the idea of Eileen (as I googled her name) cheating on Doc Hayward. I dunno whatever maybe she and the doc change their Facebook status to “it’s complicated”
Catherine DEFINITELY lives happily ever after and gets to develop Ghostwood because as a conniving woman who put up with a bunch of dudes’ bullshit she deserves it.
Ben continues to be a sleazy, gross, disgusting goof who is compensating constantly and as Catherine develops Ghostwood he falls deeper into environmental activism until he becomes so immersed he actually starts to believe his own bullshit.
Um… James realizes he’s gay and stays in San Francisco in the castro district.
Donna Hayward goes to Bennington in Vermont and is super fucking annoying and writes bad poetry.
Audrey becomes a very successful business woman and restores and keeps the Great Northern going after her dad falls off the sanity wagon. She dates that dude who’s really into her but she’s not as into him and is more into her career but likes having a steady boyfriend who is in love with her.
Annie and Cooper get married, awww. Harry is his best man obviously and Andy, Hawk, and Albert are all groomsmen.
And there’s definitely NO Showtime revival with Amanda Seyfried and evil Dale Cooper and Dale Cooper never raped Diane or anything like that and we don’t go down that fucking rabbit hole because it’s too dark of a turn for this show when the show’s merits in the first place were moments like Albert saying his concerns were global and that he was a naysayer and hatchet-man in the fight against violence and when Dale Cooper said he was talking about viewing the world through love.